Wednesday, August 11, 2010

"Hi, I'm a Mac... And I love being in the classroom!"



About two years ago, I ended an almost 20 year relationship.

I was surprised how abruptly it ended, but that was hardly my fault. One day, we were communicating, really connecting each other. The next day, I press her power button, and nothing… No reassuring orchestral chords, a flicker of the monitor, or the flash of indicator lights above the keyboard that started each day. Perhaps I shouldn’t have been surprised considering our tumultuous history together, but in the end I had to walk away. Starring back at the lifeless screen, an abysmal void of digital nothingness, the inevitable had arrived.

So I made “the switch” and purchased a MacBook. Since then, I can say in all honesty that it’s probably one of the top ten decisions I’ve ever made in my entire life (so far). Mac’s dependability, ease of use, and quality of performance is vastly superior to a Windows’ unavoidable glitchiness, sluggish performance, and notorious “blue screen of death”. I can’t count how many times my PC laptop would freeze up or crash on me, yet the number of times my Mac has crashed or frozen up on me has numbered probably no more than 5 incidences. Most of those were due to my own short-sightedness; too many applications open or processes going on at once.

Sure, I miss some of the versatility of my old PC; being able to play a multitude of games on it, most namely. But I gave all that up in a heartbeat for the sheer reliable performance I get from my Mac. Like a Timex watch, it takes a lickin’ and keeps on tickin’, and starts up every time I press the power button! With programs like IMovie and GarageBand, I’ve been able to edit my own movies with professional effects or simply record a song with multiple tracks. Quite simply, my Mac does everything I ask it to in a hassle-free, user-friendly interface. It makes PCs seem like a ticking time bomb.

Likewise, when I think of using Mac’s in a classroom, I couldn’t recommend it enough .We tend to associate the word “quality” with education, so why should it not apply to the technology students use to express that learning? Considering the level of performance commonly associated with a Mac which I mentioned above, it makes sense for schools to invest in technology that is made to last. We’ve all heard in the news of school budget cuts threatening jobs and extracurricular programs alike. Tighter budgets means curtailed spending. True, Macs are not cheap (my particular MacBook retailed at $1400 two years ago), but does it make more sense for schools to purchase $500 Dell laptops every 2-3 years, after which point they will eventually degrade in quality and performance after extended use, or twice as much on Macs that could potentially last twice as long? The fact is, who wouldn’t want students to have access to technology and materials (uniforms, equipment, textbooks, desks, etc.) that will remain useful with quality intact through each successive school year.

But what can classrooms do once they have Macs? Apple has long been dedicated to education and informing teachers how they can extend their student’s learning through the use of Mac’s various applications in practical classroom settings. While the Apple website lists various selling points, I’ll speak from my own experience here.

After I shot my first short film, I used IMovie ’08 to compile the footage, edit, add effects, music, and export it into a finished product. All this might sound like rather tedious and complicated process, but believe me when I say that IMovie is so easy to use a 5 year old could do it. Using an uncomplicated “drag-and-drop” interface, anyone can use IMovie to create sharp looking clips and films for practically any project or occasion. Whether this is a class or individual project, newscast, digital storytelling, presentation or a simple demonstration, IMovie is well-suited to any level of experience – from beginners who need a more guided approach toward programs such as IMovie, to students who are fluent enough to use IMovie without assistance. IMovie accommodates a broad range of abilities. This website has an exhaustive list of suggestions and examples of IMovie uses in the classroom.

While I haven’t used GarageBand as extensively (just once), I’m familiar with its various uses including the ability to create and edit podcasts, interviews, or radio shows. I remember hearing about a 4th grade classroom here in Lincoln who created a 1930s radio broadcast using GarageBand software while they studied the Great Depression. Again, like IMovie, GarageBand has a minimal learning curve, meaning it doesn’t take long before you’re familiar with it enough to use some of its more advanced features. Music teachers could use GarageBand to create recordings or even record multiple tracks. Think of choir rehearsal: A soprano section could easily record their part for the bass section to playback during sectionals. Just a suggestion, and there are many other lesson plans and ideas out there for how to incorporate Mac applications in the classroom. Again, the beauty of Mac applications is that they’re simple enough anyone can use, and designed to be user-friendly, clean, and sophisticated. By default, this lends a spirit of collaboration, creativity, innovation, and possibility to the technology-driven classroom.

I could go on and on explaining the many ways Macs can be used in the classroom, but it's best to see it in action. I found this GREAT video, which shows how Mac applications are integrated with one another for students to create a presentation about the Middle Ages using IMovie '09. Notice how they got to use their IPod Touches to do research and compile pictures they'd eventually use in the presentations.

Sorry, PC, but it just wasn’t meant to be.


6 comments:

  1. That last image just cracks me up! I have always been a PC user and have just about had enough! We just received our district laptops, round two in the last 5 years or so. My "new" lap top is SOOOOOO slow. I'm constantly restarting in hopes for better luck. I have to say I would be willing to make the switch. Interesting enough, all of our elementary teachers/schools have Macs, and all of our secondary have PCs.... have to say I'm kinda jealous of the elementary crew!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I am a Mac fan too! I also started on the PC and my life changed and become better when I took the plunge with the Mac. Because I use mine mainly for art and graphic design work the screen quality is what initially drew me in. Not to mention how much faster and better they process large files.

    It was a transition that did take some adjusting though; it did take me a few tries to figure out how to eject a cod, but the over all performance and simplicity of a Mac is worth it.

    Never having to use virus programs and spyware junk is another bonus!

    YAY for MACS!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Nice evaluation of the options and a good recommendation. Having recently gotten an iMac for home to develop iPhone applications I'm not doing well on the mac =(

    I think you're right in the direction of your post - it should be an either/or for use of the Mac or PC. Constantly switching back and forth gets me very frustrated since a lot of the commands do not work. It was interesting to see the integration of iPods for each student to use and then collaborate on the larger workstation. That seems to be an innovation solution to not having enough computers in the classroom since an iPod, connected to the web, can function very similar to a desktop computer.


    One point that may help muddle the waters is that at my school the iMacs have dual boot mode - where you can run either OS X or Windows XP. It's neat that when you turn on the computer there is a screen asking if you want to use the computer as a Mac or as a Microsoft PC using Windows.

    Finally, I wonder how much longer this discussion will even be relevant given the move towards cloud computer and web based applications. I thought Netbooks were going to make a larger splash and I wonder if the iPad will complete the move - but if we just start using web based applications (like Google Documents instead of word or open office) than the operating system doesn't really matter. Interesting to see where this ends up!

    ReplyDelete
  4. I know the feeling of saying goodbye to a technological friend. My computer finally went from the "blue screen of death" to a black screen that informed me that there was an error on the hard drive and it could not run because of it. :'( I have never been so happy to have everything on my external hard drive before in my life.

    I am in the process of selecting a Mac as its replacement. I have heard of the reliability you have mentioned and I know they were designed to better handle all of the computer graphics and photo work I desire to do in the future. It is also the computer that I learned all of the adobe software on, so I know what the commands are on that computer.

    I love how there are so many different options you have for activities when you think about using a Mac. THere are video, photo, and compositions activities that would allow for a lot of creativity. It would also give a lot of hands on stuff to do.
    I have had some people tell me that the Mac and PC have become more and more similar as the years progress. Have you heard anything of that nature while you were looking up information?


    Danny- you are boggling my mind with your last paragraph. I have not payed that much attention to the different new technological toys they have created. I don't have the money to buy them so I know different things about PCs and Macs but not much of the other things that come out. It is another thing that makes me realize how much more is out there then what I see on a daily basis. I think I also tend to be one of those people that will use what she is familiar with because I don't have the time, at this point, to figure out how to use something else.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Our technology director had to do some research on the history of technology at our school for her masters class. She found out why we became a Mac school in the early 90s. It came down to a simple decision. Macs were more expensive but required much less maintenance. PCs were cheaper but required more maintenance. The teachers in charge of technology at the time decided that they could always find money to pay for the Macs. They decided that time was more difficult to find, especially since they were also classroom teachers. Therefore the decision was made to go with Mac. I am very thankful for their foresight.

    I was a PC all the way until I began teaching. When I arrived at Zion, I became sold on the Mac immediately, and the next time my family bought a computer, we purchased an iMac.

    Once you go Mac, you never go back!

    ReplyDelete
  6. Danny,

    I think the next five years will be very interesting with the move toward cloud computing and web based/Web 2.0 applications. The one issue for Mac users is the amount of Web 2.0 tools that are flash based and therefore do not work on the iPad or the iPod. I think my school would have bought iPads this summer if they would work with flash and do a better job with Google docs. We probably 40 macbooks instead and probably could have purchased 60-80 iPads instead.

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.